Fair Use Note

WARNING for European visitors: European Union laws require you to give European Union visitors information about cookies used on your blog. In many cases, these laws also require you to obtain consent. As a courtesy, we have added a notice on your blog to explain Google's use of certain Blogger and Google cookies, including use of Google Analytics and AdSense cookies. You are responsible for confirming this notice actually works for your blog, and that it displays. If you employ other cookies, for example by adding third party features, this notice may not work for you. Learn more about this notice and your responsibilities.

Thomas Paine

To argue with a person who has renounced the use of reason is like administering medicine to the dead.
Showing posts with label water despotism floods pollution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label water despotism floods pollution. Show all posts

Saturday, August 21, 2010

21 Aug - Flood,Famine, and Thirst

Mountains in LadakhImage via Wikipedia

LATEST HEADLINES:

Environmentalists want Interior Secretary Ken Salazar out
http://www.examiner.com/environmental-policy-in-national/environmentalists-want-interior-secretary-ken-salazar-out

On June 14, a letter, spearheaded by WildEarth Guardians, and signed by hundreds of conservationists and scientists, was sent to the White House, calling for Ken Salazar’s resignation.
“Mr. Salazar’s failure to clean up Interior is why we’re seeing the mess in the Gulf. We need serious mopping up within this department, and it should start with Salazar leaving,” said Nicole Rosmarino of WildEarth Guardians.
The environmentalist’s letter describes details of how Salazar has failed to live up to his tough talk of being the “new sheriff in town”. He has been totally ineffectual in cleaning up the corruption in multiple agencies within the department. But environmentalists are not the only ones unimpressed with Salazar’s record.
Former Secretary of Interior Bruce Babbitt has been extremely critical of Salazar’s plan to reform MMS and agrees that it doesn’t go far enough.
Babbitt likened it to “rearranging the chairs on the deck of the Titanic” and said oversight of oil industry regulations should be shifted to the EPA.

    Pak Nationalists

    • Leaks Destroy America’s Case Against ISI



      Videos  (2 )

      Ahmed Quraishi: India’s Covert War In Afghanistan

      Pakistan Exercise: Military War Games Near India Border

      India Causes Fresh Pakistan Floods

      While Pakistani foreign minister and his government were busy accepting Indian aid for Pakistani flood victims, New Delhi released a massive 18,000 cusec feet of water from a dam in Indian-occupied Kashmir into Pakistan, prompting fresh fears of floods in the plains of Punjab and Sindh.
      No comment

      Who Really Controls Shahbaz Air Base?

      Pakistan Air Force arranged a hurriedly organized media tour yesterday to prove that the base is not under US control. But this does not appear to be the whole truth.According GlobalSecurity.org, Pakistani newspaper Daily Times claimed on 10 March 2004 that the airbase was under US control, “with an inner ring of facilities off-limits to Pakistan's military,” according to the paper. But in August 2010, there is credible information that new special residential barracks for US personnel have been constructed. Unfortunately, Pakistan has accepted to house US personnel who will ensure the country’s doesn’t ‘misuse’ the new F-16s. So despite PAF’s – and US Embassy’s – sharp reaction, it is clear there is some merit to the statement of Federal Health Secretary Kamran Lashari that US presence at the base is preventing using the base for flood relief operations.
      No comment

      Where Are Pakistan’s Millionaire Politicians?

      While the world’s rich dole out money to help Pakistan’s flood victims, Pakistan’s filthy rich politicians refuse to budge. See who is paying what.
      No comment

      Pakistani Media Supporting The Wrong Democrats

      This episode is important because it shows once again the basic structural flaws in the Pakistani political system and the Pakistani democracy which lead this system to repeatedly crash and throw the country back to square one, wasting precious time that we don’t have.
      3 comments

      Pakistani Democracy Has Drowned In The Floods

      These politicians have no idea as to how to solve the problems of the country. Moreover, these secular democrats have no popular domestic support and are dependent upon the patronage of their Western masters.
      No comment

      India Causes Fresh Pakistan Floods

      While Pakistani foreign minister and his government were busy accepting Indian aid for Pakistani flood victims, New Delhi released a massive 18,000 cusec feet of water from a dam in Indian-occupied Kashmir into Pakistan, prompting fresh fears of floods in the plains of Punjab and Sindh.
      No comment

      Who Really Controls Shahbaz Air Base?

      Pakistan Air Force arranged a hurriedly organized media tour yesterday to prove that the base is not under US control. But this does not appear to be the whole truth.According GlobalSecurity.org, Pakistani newspaper Daily Times claimed on 10 March 2004 that the airbase was under US control, “with an inner ring of facilities off-limits to Pakistan's military,” according to the paper. But in August 2010, there is credible information that new special residential barracks for US personnel have been constructed. Unfortunately, Pakistan has accepted to house US personnel who will ensure the country’s doesn’t ‘misuse’ the new F-16s. So despite PAF’s – and US Embassy’s – sharp reaction, it is clear there is some merit to the statement of Federal Health Secretary Kamran Lashari that US presence at the base is preventing using the base for flood relief operations.
      No comment

      Check Indian, Afghan Dams For Floods In Pakistan

      It’s not as if the clouds dodged borders and focused on Pakistan only. Pakistan’s water flows from Indian-occupied Kashmir and from US-occupied Afghanistan. A natural deluge should have shown some spillover effect into Indian and Afghan regions adjoining Pakistan. It is interesting that a second and a third wave of floods is expected in Pakistan when there’s no rain to justify it. Where is the water coming from? Here’s a perspective by Mr. Zaid Hamid, a security analyst at BrassTacks, and Ms. Gulpari Mehsud, a researcher at PakNationalists.com.
      1 comment
      Backgrounder from Water - Wealth & Power
      www.internationalrivers.org/files/IR_Himalayas_rev.pdf 
      Mountains of concrete: Dam building in the Himalayas - A report by International Rivers
      http://www.indiawaterportal.org/node/12126
      A review of existing evidence and the arguments raised by a number of experts highlight the following points:
          * There is very little evidence to establish that big dams are the only, the best or the optimal solution to the electricity question.
          * While these projects will undoubtedly generate many thousands of units of electricity, it does not mean that they will help improve access to power for the poor and the vulnerable sections of society.
          * The high cost of these projects, their long distances from load centres, the increasing need for privatisation of these projects and the incentives and tax breaks being offered to attract private companies, are all likely to result in high costs of electricity, which will only benefit the sections of society with a high paying capacity.
          * These projects are likely to have huge social, environmental and cultural impacts, which will be especially harsh on locals, tribal people, farmers and others living in the remote valleys of the Himalayas.
          * The downstream impacts of the proposed projects will also be serious, and will be felt in areas from just downstream of the projects all the way to the plains and the deltas.
          * Experts have also been concerned about the cumulative impacts of what is likely to be the highest concentration of dams in the world, in a region that is ecologically fragile.
          * Many have raised concerns about the way in which the decisions for the construction of the dams have been taken without taking into consideration the views of the people who will be most affected by the dams. Similarly, social, environmental and cultural issues have not been given any considerations in the decision-making processes.

      India Expected To Raise Tension With Pakistan During Commonwealth Games

      Pakistani analysts are worried that New Delhi might resort to false flag operations or a mock terror threat to sidetrack media attention from the mess surrounding the games. In all probability, India could use one of the many Hindu terror groups to mount attacks that would be blamed on Pakistan. India has seen a mushrooming of Hindu terror groups over the past decade.
      No comment

      Pakistani Media Supporting The Wrong Democrats

      This episode is important because it shows once again the basic structural flaws in the Pakistani political system and the Pakistani democracy which lead this system to repeatedly crash and throw the country back to square one, wasting precious time that we don’t have
      We Killed The Goose That Laid The Golden Egg And Now The Number Of Americans Receiving Long-Term Unemployment Benefits Has Risen A Whopping 60 Percent In Just One Year
      http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/we-killed-the-goose-that-laid-the-golden-egg-and-now-the-number-of-americans-receiving-long-term-unemployment-benefits-has-risen-a-whopping-60-percent-in-just-one-year
      10 Signs The U.S. is Becoming a Third World Country
      http://www.informationliberation.com/?id=31813
      The general designations of the ranking system for world status date back to the 1950s, and have included countries at various stages of economic development. Since the Cold War, the definition has come to be synonymous with repressive countries where a wealthy class of ruling elites segment society into the haves and have-nots, many times capitalizing on the conditions that follow an economic crisis or war.
      •  
      Germany and Its Industrial Rise: Due to No Copyright
      http://www.informationliberation.com/?id=31825
      Of Motes, Beams, and Holy Wars
      http://freedominourtime.blogspot.com/2010/08/of-motes-beams-and-holy-wars.html
      A lawsuit filed in late 2008 by the Thomas More Law Center on behalf of Iraq War veteran Kevin J. Murray accuses the federal government (particularly Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner and the Federal Reserve's Board of Governors) of violating Madison's "three pence" standard by indirectly financing "Sharia-Compliant" investments by way of the American International Group (AIG).
      How can it be an unendurable affront to be forced to surrender "three pence" to promote Sharia-compliant investments, when the Regime ruling us has spent three trillion (and counting) to impose Sharia law at gunpoint?
      Obama Demands Access to Internet Records, in Secret, and Without Court Review
      http://www.informationliberation.com/?id=31795
      Under cover of coughing-up information deemed relevant to espionage or terrorism investigations, proposed changes to the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA) would greatly expand the volume of private records that can be seized through National Security Letters (NSLs).
      Constitution-shredding lettres de cachet, NSLs are administrative subpoenas that can be executed by agencies such as the FBI, CIA or Defense Department, solely on the say so of supervisory agents.
      The noxious warrants are not subject to court review, nor can a recipient even disclose they have received one. Because of their secretive nature, they are extremely difficult to challenge.
      Issued by unaccountable Executive Branch agents hiding behind a façade of top secret classifications and much-ballyhooed "sources and methods," NSLs clearly violate our constitutional rights.
      The fourth amendment unambiguously states: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."
      However, in "new normal" America constitutional guarantees and civil rights are mere technicalities, cynical propaganda exercises jettisoned under the flimsiest of pretexts: the endless "War on Terror" where the corporate state's praetorian guards work the "dark side."
      Once served, firms such as telecommunication providers, banks, credit card companies, airlines, health insurers, video rental services, even booksellers and libraries, are compelled to turn over what the secret state deem relevant records on targets of FBI fishing expeditions.
      If burdensome NSL restrictions are breeched for any reason, that person can be fined or even jailed if gag orders built into the draconian USA Patriot Act are violated.
      However, even the Patriot Act's abysmally lowered threshold for seizing private records specify that NSLs cannot be issued "solely on the basis of activities protected by the first amendment of the Constitution of the United States."
      Despite these loose standards, congressional investigators, journalists and civil liberties watchdogs found that the FBI violated the rules of the road, such as they are, thousands of times. Between 2003-2006, the Bureau issued 192,499 NSLs, according to current estimates, the FBI continues to hand out tens of thousands more each year.
      The Hidden Tragedy of the CIA's Experiments on Children
      http://www.truth-out.org/the-hidden-tragedy-cias-experiments-children62208
       Here it should be noted that, during the cold war years, CIA and Army Counter-Intelligence Corps (CIC) interrogators, working as part of projects Bluebird and Artichoke, sometimes injected large amounts of Metrazol into selected enemy or Communist agents for the purposes of severely frightening other suspected agents, by forcing them to observe the procedure. The almost immediate effects of Metrazol are shocking for many to witness: subjects will shake violently, twisting and turning. They typically arch, jerk and contort their bodies and grimace in pain. With Metrazol, as with electroshock, bone fractures - including broken necks and backs - and joint dislocations are not uncommon, unless strong sedatives are administered beforehand.
      A November 1936 Time magazine article seriously questioned the benefits of Metrazol, citing "irreversible shock" as a "great danger." The article described a typical Metrazol injection as such: "A patient receives no food for four or five hours. Then about five cubic centimeters of the drug [Metrazol] are injected into his veins. In about half-a-minute he coughs, casts terrified glances around the room, twitches violently, utters a horse wail, freezes into rigidity with his mouth wide open, arms and legs stiff as boards. Then he goes into convulsions. In one or two minutes the convulsions are over and he gradually passes into a coma, which lasts about an hour. After a series of shocks, his mind may be swept clean of delusions.... A patient is seldom given more than 20 injections and if no improvement is noted after ten treatments, he is usually given up as hopeless."
      The Untold History of Controlling the Masses Through the Manipulation of Unconscious Desires
      http://www.informationliberation.com/?id=8339
      The story of the relationship between Sigmund Freud and his American nephew, Edward Bernays. Bernays invented the public relations profession in the 1920s and was the first person to take Freud's ideas to manipulate the masses. He showed American corporations how they could make people want things they didn't need by systematically linking mass-produced goods to their unconscious desires.
      Bernays was one of the main architects of the modern techniques of mass-consumer persuasion, using every trick in the book, from celebrity endorsement and outrageous PR stunts, to eroticising the motorcar.
      His most notorious coup was breaking the taboo on women smoking by persuading them that cigarettes were a symbol of independence and freedom. But Bernays was convinced that this was more than just a way of selling consumer goods. It was a new political idea of how to control the masses. By satisfying the inner irrational desires that his uncle had identified, people could be made happy and thus docile.
      It was the start of the all-consuming self which has come to dominate today's world.
      The story of the relationship between Sigmund Freud and his American nephew, Edward Bernays. Bernays invented the public relations profession in the 1920s and was the first person to take Freud's ideas to manipulate the masses. He showed American corporations how they could make people want things they didn't need by systematically linking mass-produced goods to their unconscious desires.
      Bernays was one of the main architects of the modern techniques of mass-consumer persuasion, using every trick in the book, from celebrity endorsement and outrageous PR stunts, to eroticising the motorcar.
      His most notorious coup was breaking the taboo on women smoking by persuading them that cigarettes were a symbol of independence and freedom. But Bernays was convinced that this was more than just a way of selling consumer goods. It was a new political idea of how to control the masses. By satisfying the inner irrational desires that his uncle had identified, people could be made happy and thus docile.
      It was the start of the all-consuming self which has come to dominate today's world.
      Despite these loose standards, congressional investigators, journalists and civil liberties watchdogs found that the FBI violated the rules of the road, such as they are, thousands of times. Between 2003-2006, the Bureau issued 192,499 NSLs, according to current estimates, the FBI continues to hand out tens of thousands more each year.
      Worldwide Campaign to Save the Grand Canyon
      http://sen4earth.org/articles/demand-govt-action/worldwide-campaign-to-save-the-grand-canyon
      When we speak of the Grand Canyon, we refer to not only the Canyon itself, but also include the vast and surrounding areas such as the Colorado River Drainage Basin and it’s ecosystem, a vital source of water to wildlife and millions of people, numerous wildlife refuges, surrounding designated park and wildlife areas, communities, and cities. The fate of millions of lives are dependent upon and affected by all that happens in and around the Grand Canyon ~ the fate of these lives is in our hands.
       ( It isn't just uranium mining runoff. Exploration itself causes great damage. Do you need strong encouragement to stop permanent 'poisoning of the well'  ?  Entries are mostly under 'Uranium - Mining and Depleted'  in the Topical Index
    Enhanced by Zemanta

    Sunday, July 12, 2009

    Indian Water Woes

    Bottling livelihoods

    Dropping ground water levels and gross soil pollution in Varanasi district, UttarPradesh, prompt a fresh crop of protest actions against Coca-Cola. For its part the corporation attempts to resolve the conflict by ‘educating’ its critics, and issuing tenuous claims against evidence of environmental degradation.

    Flash floods: Misery imposed by men, not nature

    One early morning on February 6th even as bureaucrats of Social Justice and Empowerment Ministry rushed to their office, men and women from Narmada valley had arrived to knock the gates of the ministry. Since the deadline to rehabilitate them (December 31, if the dam builders wished to raise the dam height before monsoon 2006) had passed by, the oustees were visibly angry and sought an explanation why the ministry responsible for keeping an oversight on rehabilitation progress actively encouraged the false Action Taken Reports, reportedly being sent to it by Narmada Valley Development Authority and Narmada Control Authority

    They returned to their villages only to recollect a month later that the dam building corporation and state governments backing it were acting surreptitiously to manage the clearance to raise the Sardar Sarovar dam’s height to 121.92 mts. 

     These disciplined people were routinely dragged, beaten and detained by those who supposedly keep the law and order in place

    Narmada debate has entered a decisive phase and the onset of monsoon will tell which way will people go: embracing the watery graves brought in with submergence without rehabilitation – which is almost imminent and can’t be undone by the patchwork of rehabilitation oversight within a month – or resorting to the option of armed resistance.

    The Supreme Court gave an order on the petition by oustees. The order upheld the contention of the petitioners that the rehabilitation process was reduced to a game of numbers (hyperlink article http://www.indiatogether.org/2005/apr/hrt-dampafs.htm) where the number of affected families was constantly in flux. MP government had maneuvered to diminish the number of affected persons by introducing an arbitrary distinction of permanent and temporary submergence. I had called this process “forced disappearance”, whereby the best way to rehabilitate displaced persons turned out to be a three-stage process, without venturing into submergence village at any stage.

    These three stages were:
    To make a list, 
    Then take thousands of people off the list,
    Show that those to be rehabilitated have been granted cash compensation cheques by post.

    September 2006: Update from the author
    What makes submergence, water logging and flash floods so different from floods? A simple pointer that while the former results from ill-advised decisions taken by individuals, who remain shielded by a system that is shrouded under the culture of secrecy, the latter has been a natural phenomenon just like rainfall or a river is. 

    The debate is slowly raging that this year's flash floods flowed out of negligent dam operations, and not from incessant rainfall within a matter of few days or rivers rising suddenly and flowing in spate. A look back at similar incidents and media's role in past few years indicate that how easily it debunked critical thinking and chose to flow with official viewpoint; unless it came to a hugely populated city going under waters due to flash floods in Tapti river downstream of Ukai dam.
    So a monsoon later, how effectively and optimally have dam operators in Gujarat utilized the impounded water in reservoir over Narmada? It was widely reported in Gujarati newspapers that Narmada Main Canal was breached at several places and since July 28th it was carrying meager 580 cubic feet water per second, even as the inflow of water at Sardar Sarovar dam was 23000 cubic feet per second. As meager flow into irrigation canals along with incessant rains upstream led to sudden rise of water levels, releases into the river through the powerhouse were just 21,000 cusecs till the dam started overflowing from August 2nd onwards. Far from taking impounded waters to other rivers through irrigation canal, Gujarat couldn't utilize the waters impounded in the reservoir, taking the water level to a high 128 meters within a matter of a week spelling doom for downstream villages and Bharuch.

    Rewind one more year. Two years ago, on August 3rd 2004, UNI reported that Narmada main canal collapsed at two places near Bodeli, inundating villages and rendering hundreds of villagers homeless. Within a week, on August 11th, PTI Bhasha had flashed similar news, reporting of collapse of Narmada canal in Viramgam Taluka in Ahmedabad district.

    Neither of the incidents of collapse of main canal was followed with incisive and analytical follow up by mainstream media. During past two years ad hoc administration of irrigation establishment didn't come under public gaze, as media actively overflowed along with official view. Those who tried to battle against silencing of untold miseries suffered by people due to water logging, submergence and flash floods downstream were belittled by them. An overflowing dam that attracted thousands to behold it in awe didn't allow any questions on what havoc did it spell on submergence affected people, or what untold misery can it spell for people living downstream?

    So the pertinent question is, why did Surat got submerged, with the backlash of high tide raising the backwater level alike the rising waters in submergence zone of dams?

    Just prior to the onset of this year's monsoon, water level in Ukai dam was 21.56 % of the reservoir capacity, and by July 20th it was already 51 % (i.e. half) filled, as per Central Water Commission data.

    Within next ten days, water level at dam site rose and on July 30th it stood at 322.93 feet, which is around 22 feet below the Full Reservoir Level, as per an UNI news release. The same news release had quoted floods control room sources at Surat claiming that Tapti river was flowing six meters below danger mark, clearly indicating that even as the reservoir was filing up very fast, authorities had not scheduled downstream releases in a phased manner!

    While four days later, on August 3rd, reservoir was filled to 77.54% of the storage capacity, the irrigation minister was heard pressing at a press briefing on August 2nd, "till August 15th waters will not be released from Ukai dam", as revealed now by IANS correspondent. Authorities waited for three more days before hitting the panic button by hastily opening the floodgates of Ukai on August 6th, the waters started steadily rising in Tapti river downstream. Next day, by the afternoon water level in 345.6 feet high Ukai dam had risen up to 341 feet and they started releasing 7 to 8 lakh cusecs waters downstream as per news agency reports. By the night, the downstream releases went up to 10 lakh cusecs. By this time large part of Surat had already submerged under water, but on August 8th as well, dam authorities continued releasing 10 lakh cusecs water, while authorities bluffed misleading certain news agencies that "now it had decided to allow water levels to go up to 344.8 feet". On August 9th, the volume of waters release form Ukai dam had come down to 7.50 lakh cusecs, however, there was no respite for Surat, as it coincided with high tide in the sea on full moon day, not allowing the waters to recede.

    And while the meager amount of statistics that are available from various news agency reports and UNDP's situation reports make out a strong case pointing a finger at negligent dam operation by Ukai dam authorities, in a statement published by The Indian Express on August 13th, S R Rao, Principal Secretary, Urban Development chose to give a clean chit to Ukai authorities; "I have checked all statistics. None including you could have prevented this" (emphasis supplied).

    On August 11th, the same newspaper had carried a news story titled Don't fault nature, Surat's misery man made, in which N K Singh reported, "Gujarat government has been reluctant to disclose official data related to inflow and outflow of water. Revenue Minister Kaushik Patel refused to share the details at a press meet in Gandhinagar and walked out in a huff when media persons quizzed him on the releases of water."

    Himanshu Thakkar, director of South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People says, "The trouble is, so long as our water bureaucracy remains non-transparent and unaccountable, disasters like the current one won't leave us soon. The least one can demand is a credible, independent enquiry on why such a situation arose. Especially when it was one that could have been substantially avoided with more optimal operation of projects."